Marc Sabatella said:
Yep, that's a "controlled vocabulary" issue - exactly the same thing that comes up when keywording images.
but usually when keywording images, you are using your keywords for your own use, so you will (most likely) re-use the same words. (depending on how much you had to drink before a particular keywording session.) :)
That' one reaosn it is nice that there is a (sort of) predefined set of tags on display to select from, if people could get into the habit of doing that. is that really reaosnable to expect? I don't know.
Lets look at what we are doing already with the pre-defined set. First, this topic has been tagged 'tips'. The pre-defined set has 'how to' as the closest representative option to 'tips'. So now we have seperate how-to's so already I have two different places to look for the same thing. Suppose you need a pair of jeans, you go to Walmart and tell the associate "I need some new jeans, where can I find them?" "well we keep some in aisle 27 and there are a few in aisle 4, think I saw one associate putting jeans in aisle 88 (must be a super-walmart eh?) and we've got the sale one's near the back and...." You want some flippin jeans, you don't want to have to run around looking several places... same with tips, how-tos, tricks, etc.
You might be thinking, ok isolated instance... how about 'pan lock' and 'panlock' up there... same exact thing but whoever setup the pre-defined set, they did it to ways and now you will find 4 posts in one, but 3 posts in the other... or 'crash', 'crashes', and 'crashing'. again same thing, but only one post is duplicated in two of the variations and the third variation has completely different posts. So this has been up what, 3 weeks? Can you imaging the rat's nest this will be in a year if someone doesn't go 'duh! what were we thinking?' and do something quickly?
Lots of things seem like they might be hard to get used to first, and now we can't imagine how we do without them.
Personally, I could get by without having to get used to looking in 5 different places in one store just to pick out one pair of jeans. I like efficiency. And it doesn't happen by accident, you have to design for it.
I personally had to be dragged kicking and screaming into using a mouse or a window-based interface, so accustomed to the keyboard / command-line based OS interfaces of the 70's and early 80's. Now I couldn't imagine going back.
Some new things are good, I agree. But do you remember having your program entirely in one directory, not having files here and there after installing your program because 'installing' was just copying into it's very own directory? You needed to copy that program to another computer, you copied everything in the directory and copied them into their own directory on the new computer and everything worked like it did before? And no one knew or cared what the system registry was and how it got corrupted? I like the GUI and the mouse and all that, but man, there was a lot to be said for the old days of DOS. You could install 20 more graphics programs and ACDSee still ran just like when it was fresh installed (hypothetical here). :)
And ya know what else? All of this effort of discussing all this may be just a moot point, because no one from ACDSee is willing to post a list on here of the things they have approved and are working on, or are they willing to become actively involved in their own blog thingy enough to give real answers to the customer asking and making requests, etc. I use Zenfolio as a photo sharing site. They are a relatively new player in that area, growing and evolving as quickly as they can, and have a lot of customers making requests and asking questions in their forum areas. And in most of those, you will find the top two persons at ZF are actively involved in the forums and they keep a list of items they are working on and towards so customers are informed. Really makes you feel like they care about you as a customer.
Posted On October 4, 2008 - 08:26 PM (1 year ago) (
Permalink to this post)